Why good ideas get dismissed
Most people judge our thinking by how good it sounds. If you're organized, choose your words well and speak with confidence, they often assume your thinking is good. If you jump between points, stumble over your words, or can't quite finish a thought, they assume it isn't. But the best ideas are rarely presented perfectly.
Some of the most valuable thinking comes out messy. The words don't quite fit, the sentence trails off, the explanation behind the idea is incomplete.
People tend to judge the outward expression of an idea rather than the idea itself. A well-phrased average idea often gets further than a strong idea phrased badly. And if your thinking is complex and wide-ranging, it can be harder to put into words cleanly, because there's so much more to translate.
It isn't only the words. Brilliant thinkers don't always look confident or charismatic when they share an idea. When they're deep in their processing, they can seem distant or hard to connect with, because most of their attention is on the thinking itself.
The best ideas often take shape in conversation, when someone asks a question, the idea gets explained a second or third time, and it becomes clearer to everyone, including the person who had it.
So if we're seeking good ideas, we want fewer perfect presentations and more casual conversations.
Gregor